Umbrellas vs Softboxes in Photography Studio | FD Photo Studio
Studio Rating  from over 277 Reviews

Umbrellas vs Softboxes in Photography Studio

Umbrellas vs Softboxes in Photography Studio

Most professional photo studio photographers ask themselves if they should use an umbrella or softbox when looking for a light modifier with flash photography. Since both umbrellas and softboxes have their uses, it really depends on the type of lighting effect you’re hoping to achieve.

When shooting through an umbrella you’re apt to get softer light, while a reflective umbrella allows you to control the lighting by giving it more direction. Just remember that the light will be harder when a source is further away from the subject and softer the closer it is to the subject.

A softbox lets you change the lighting’s direction, so you may want to move it around the subject to find the most effective angle. You can do this by setting your aperture for the shoot to find the depth of field you want and then move the softbox while taking test photos from different angles. If the images show uneven, harsh lighting on your subject or strong contrast you should move the softbox to make sure the light is in front of the subject instead of at an angle. But if the lighting appears to be too flat you should consider giving it more of an angle.

Umbrellas

When it comes to umbrellas, they’re relatively inexpensive and quite easy to use and there are two basic types: the shoot-through and the reflective version. These devices, which are available in various sizes and shapes, can produce a soft and broad light source which is similar to outdoor lighting.

Umbrellas vs Softboxes in Photography Studio  -

If an umbrella is used in its traditional position it will offer indirect, bounced light which could require a greater flash output from the light source. Beginners usually find a white translucent shoot-through umbrella easy to work with since it produces broad lighting. A shoot-through umbrella just needs to be positioned between the flash and the subject and in general, larger umbrellas produce softer light.

Silver Reflective Umbrella

This type of umbrella functions when you point the flash away from the subject and the umbrella will bounce the light back onto the person. They’re ideal for shooting groups of people as they provide simple and even lighting. Another type of fashionable umbrella is the parabolic umbrella. This device can create high specularity in the light as the umbrellas can focus the flash pattern.

Softboxes

Most softboxes are rectangular in shape, but you can also find square and octagonal versions. They emulate window light, which means it’s soft and directional, with the key being directional. The flash is fired directly through a softbox which produces direct lighting, even if a diffusion panel is used to soften the flash. Since you don’t have to rely on reflected light, the flash uses less power than when an umbrella is used.

Softboxes come in a variety of sizes and you’ll find numerous accessories can be used, such as louvers and grids which even the lighting across the plane of light. However, you may need to know how to balance the main light and fill light when using a softbox if you don’t want too much contrast. This means a softbox may be a little more complicated to use. The type of light modifier you use—an umbrella or softbox—should really depend on the type of portrait you want.

Each device can create different lighting effects. The shape of a softbox can affect the quality of the lighting. For example, long and thin softboxes are often known as striplights and can emulate stage footlights since they result in dramatic lighting. Octagonal softboxes produce direct, wraparound sources of light with even light spreads.

Umbrellas vs Softboxes

Umbrellas are more portable, but softboxes are better for emulating window light in a professional photo studio. A softbox offers less directionality than an umbrella but can provide flatter, wider and more even light, which reduces the intensity of shadow edges.

The curved shape of an umbrella offers more apparent directionality in the light with more intensity to shadow edges. It’s a good idea to familiarize yourself with both types of light modifiers as this will give you more creative options in the studio. In fact, the best option is to sometimes combine an umbrella and softbox, it just depends on your creative eye!

Rent Studio

starting from
  • Lights
  • Modifiers
  • C-Stands
  • V-Flats
  • Wi-Fi
  • MUA Station

Clients Review

My first time here and had a ball. Great experience. Beautiful view! Perfect natural lighting and had use of equipment. Great ...

READ MORE

Really enjoy using the new studios. Great natural light and the studio is well equipped with everything I would need to shoot f...

READ MORE

Used FD Studios for first time- great experience. I forgot my triggers- no problem, I was able to borrow some. Alex was a cool g...

READ MORE

Used FD multiple times for photo shoots for Volga Verdi clothing line – the results are amazing! Great rates, convenient locatio...

READ MORE

I love FD studio. This place is like a home to me :). I use this studio a lot to shoot portraits, engagements, fashion and artwor...

READ MORE

We did shooting of our products at FDPhotostudio. Reasonable price, great service and convenient location compare to other places...

READ MORE

This was my first experience of working in a professional photo studio. To tell you the truth, I didn’t quite know how to set th...

READ MORE

First time using the studio and I must say the experience was terrific. Alex was great to work with and could not be any nicer. Th...

READ MORE

Toba was fantastic to deal with throughout. From our first call to the point when we had wrapped out - she was great. Thank you...

READ MORE

The lady at the front desk helped me with setting up the light. I had a few questions and was humble in response. Definitely comin...

READ MORE

Great staff, easy to work with and very helpful.

READ MORE

Just great location and very chill!

READ MORE

I actually haven't rented studio space here yet, but I felt like I should write a review based on the customer service I've experi...

READ MORE

I have been using FD Photo Studio for the past 6 months and the experience has been nothing short of excellent. The studios are cl...

READ MORE

Great place!

READ MORE

It's BEST place to implement any ideas for photo and video shooting. The location inspires to create unique work. Thank you guys f...

READ MORE

I had a superb experience with FD Photostudio. I had no problems reserving the studio, confirming it and shooting there! The staff...

READ MORE

Having shot at FD Photo Studio for about 5 times, I can't help but say that this place is a gem in the middle of LA. It is really ...

READ MORE

The best studio in town no doubt, lots of space plus latest equipment, strongly recommend!

READ MORE

Great place! Been there for a few times and will definitely shoot more up there!

Guys who work there are cool and the ...

READ MORE

Update, I posted some snap shots of studio C. Seriously quick snap shots but you get the idea! I would love to keep the studio as...

READ MORE

I shot here a few times and have been happy each time. The staff have been more than helpful and accommodating. Parking is easy...

READ MORE

Shot at FD Photo Studio last week and it was a pleasure shooting there. They have a full bathroom with shower for models, alien...

READ MORE

This is a straight-forward studio, and works great as that. The space is very customizable. I have shot in Studio B, and am ren...

READ MORE

This studio is so dope! Great natural lighting and really cool space. They have good portions where to get ready for hair and m...

READ MORE

Stage A has great natural light and the all white paint makes for nice high key indoor window light shots. Great for quick small-s...

READ MORE

Awesome place and very good rates. Alex is always helpful . That's my first time at the new location and it's just perfect, lar...

READ MORE

I love this place! Such an inspiring and versatile studio! Great atmosphere and amazing people working there! So friendly and h...

READ MORE

I've shot at FD Photo Studio several times. The place is huge with 3 different spacious studios. I've honestly had the best exper...

READ MORE

After seven months of doing nothing I decided to do some review of what I learned in lighting and rented the studio for a while. V...

READ MORE

Great place. the set up, the rooftop access is a wonderful plus and the rates are great.

READ MORE

Everyone was so nice working there. The płace was fantastic and price was amazing. Very happy

READ MORE

Such a great studio to shoot , Studio A is really amazing with large windows to allow in natural sun light, and enough room for...

READ MORE

Love the natural lighting. Great place to shoot. Nice friendly staff.

READ MORE

LOVE this studio! SHOOT HERE!! I ll be in to shoot tomorrow for the 2nd time this week. Grateful!

READ MORE

It was great. Wish we booked more time. Definitely coming back!

READ MORE

Very friendly! Love this studio.

READ MORE

Used the studio multiple times for various projects, mostly for my product photography. They have the mannequins, steamer and a...

READ MORE

Gorgeous space, and another WINNER WINNER headshot session! I really love bringing clients to your space

READ MORE

The staff was great. Super friendly and helpful. The space is also perfect, with plenty of natural light.

READ MORE

Wonderful customer service... Always a pleasure shooting there. No issues except I wish that
someone would be available ...

READ MORE

I shot here for the very first time yesterday. Great location, great light, great studio!!! Everything you need is there. Th...

READ MORE

Toma at FD Photo Studio worked as our photo assitant during our shoot -- she is very knowledgeable and helpful! All facilities ...

READ MORE

You can tell by the lack of space in their schedules that FD Photo Studio is starting to catch on as the go-to hourly rental. Easy...

READ MORE

We recently shot our Fall 15 Product Look Book and could not be happier or more pleased with our overall experience at FD Photo St...

READ MORE

Thanks for a great video shoot. The staff was always there and very helpful. We will be booking FD Studios again soon, THANKS!!

READ MORE

Great studio spaces and value! I chose FD Photo Studios for my shoots on my recent trip to LA from Sydney Australia. Pro Studio I...

READ MORE

This place is amazing! The staff is really helpful and the place is very clean and ready to go when you arrive. For this rate, I w...

READ MORE

Our first experience with FD Studio was pretty amazing. From the helpful, really nice staff to the space itself, for the price is ...

READ MORE

Amazing space, very helpful staff. I will always continue to bring business to this studio.

READ MORE

I am the manager of a rock band in SoCal called Real Fiction. We were in need of a location to film their music video on a tight b...

READ MORE

Love the atmosphere. Great natural lighting...plus the rates are very reasonable. A+++ all around. I will be shooting there again.

READ MORE

Love this awesome studio Art 3! Will be back for more photoshoot for my next season designs for Summer 2017. Thanks FD Studio!

READ MORE

I love shooting at FD. The staff is great and the booking system is seamless and efficient. Great space and great light if you ant...

READ MORE

Anytime I"m visiting LA, FD is always my go to. Great studio space, easy to access and friendly staff.

READ MORE

Great place I just shot at Hill St. Studio 2 today and lots of Natural light plus 3 Alien Bee Strobes. Really clean and super clos...

READ MORE

I love FD studio because of their staff and of course their bright natural lighting. I also love the wooden background for art 1 a...

READ MORE

I love shooting on several of the stages this studio has to offer. The staff all have outstanding personalities and are very helpf...

READ MORE

This was an amazing collaboration with lovely models and great photographers. I worked with this Model creating a look that compli...

READ MORE

This is my go-to studio when I shoot. I absolutely love the gorgeous sets, the lighting equipment is always in great shape and rel...

READ MORE
See All Studio Reviews
FD Studios, Inc., Commercial Photographer, Los Angeles, CA